Want to walk more? A phone call may beat a text
New study
This is one study, not a conclusion. The BMJ published it on November 18, 2026, and it puts a simple idea to the test. If you want to move more, what helps you more: a person who calls you, or a phone that sends you texts?
Picture this. It's eight o'clock at night, your watch buzzes to remind you to get moving, and you swipe it away with your thumb without leaving the couch. On nights like that, your watch believes in you more than you do. Now imagine that instead of the buzz, someone calls you by name and asks how you're doing. That, more or less, is what the researchers compared.
What was tested, and on whom
The trial is called ComeBACK. Researchers at the University of Sydney led it, working with other Australian centers. They enrolled 512 adults living at home who said they found it hard or impossible to walk 800 meters (about half a mile), with or without a cane or other walking aid. They could still leave the house without physical help from another person. Their average age was 69, and 76% were women.
A random draw split participants into three groups. The first got a call from a physical therapist every two weeks for six months, as part of a broader program. The second got a six-month program of its own, built around regular text messages, but the texts were one-way, with nobody on the other end. The third went on a waitlist.
Steps were counted by a device, not by what people remembered. After six months, the team compared the average daily steps in the three groups.
The voice on the phone beat the waitlist
People in the call group averaged 7,256 steps a day. Those on the waitlist averaged 6,526. By the study's own analysis, which isn't a simple subtraction of the two averages, the calls added 931 steps a day. The likely range ran from 409 to 1,452 steps, so even at the low end it was still a gain. The calls also beat the text-message program, by 571 steps a day.
What about the text-message program compared with nothing at all? It came out 359 steps ahead, but the study couldn't rule out that the gap was due to chance. In other words, it wasn't statistically significant. So does that mean texts are useless? Not exactly. That's where the rest of the evidence comes in.
A voice on the phone vs. a reminder that expects no reply
Start with a caveat. The trial didn't measure why the calls worked better, so any explanation is a hypothesis. What it does describe is the setup. In one program, a physical therapist called every two weeks to coach you. In the other, there were messages nobody expected you to answer. The authors call the first one a person-centered intervention.
Here's an everyday observation, not a finding from the study. You can agree with a phone alert and stay right where you are. It's harder to tell someone who's calling you on Thursday that, once again, you didn't get out this week.
What the wider evidence says
Texting people to get them moving isn't a new idea. In 2020, the American Journal of Preventive Medicine published a meta-analysis by Harvard researchers that reviewed 59 studies. In the trials that counted steps with a device, text-message programs did raise daily steps compared with control groups. The authors called for larger, better-controlled trials.
Coaching has its own track record. In 2022, the American Journal of Health Promotion published another meta-analysis finding that support from a health coach increased physical activity in middle-aged adults. The effect was small, most of the studies had a substantial risk of bias, and nearly all the participants were women. What ComeBACK adds is a head-to-head comparison. The text-message program didn't make a clear difference. The calls did.
The study's limits
There are four. First, who was studied: 512 Australian adults who had trouble walking, with an average age of 69. For more than half, the main cause was several chronic conditions at once. If you're 45 and walk without any trouble, you aren't who this study looked at. Nobody knows whether the effect would be the same for you.
Second, how long it ran. The program lasted six months, and the main result was measured when it ended. The published data don't say whether the extra steps stick around afterward. Third, who paid for it. The study was funded by Australia's National Health and Medical Research Council. The authors report no financial ties in the previous three years to any organization with an interest in the work.
Fourth, this is a single trial, and it has not yet been replicated. Participants knew which group they were in, although the people who measured and analyzed the data didn't. The authors describe the effect as modest. The number of adverse events was similar across the three groups, and none were serious.
Still, it isn't the first study to point this way. In 2019, the International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health published Movingcall, a University of Basel trial of 288 adults with an average age of 42. The two intervention groups got 12 calls, one every two weeks, while the control group got written advice. With calls alone, device-measured time in moderate-to-vigorous activity rose 32 minutes a week over the control group. Adding texts didn't help further.
How to try it this week
If you want to try it, ask someone you trust to call you every two weeks and ask about your steps. A friend, your partner, or your sister will do. In return, you call them. Before you start, check the average step count your phone already keeps. Look again after a month, without changing anything else.
If you have a health condition that makes walking hard, it's a good idea to talk it over with your doctor or physical therapist first. Once the steps start adding up, it's worth paying attention to how fast you walk, because pace counts too. And if one day you get the itch to run, there's a plan to go from the couch to running one stage at a time.
If you train at Gym Triple X, you can ask the team on the gym floor to note your average step count on the day you start. Then they can ask you about it when you come back, no fuss.
Having someone ask how you're doing can help you move a bit more, and a professional does it with a method. If you're looking for that kind of follow-up in person, a personal trainer on the Costa del Sol can work with you week by week, on a plan that fits your schedule.
Sources
- BMJ (2026). Physical activity coaching and text messaging for adults with mobility limitations (ComeBACK): hybrid type 1 effectiveness implementation randomised controlled trial.
- American Journal of Preventive Medicine (2020). Text Message Interventions for Physical Activity: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis.
- American Journal of Health Promotion (2022). Effects of Health Coaching on Cardiometabolic Health in Middle-Aged Adults: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis.
- International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health (2019). Telephone-Based Coaching and Prompting for Physical Activity: Short- and Long-Term Findings of a Randomized Controlled Trial (Movingcall).