Feeling low? What lifting weights can do for your mood

Some days the hardest rep is getting up off the couch. When your mood sinks like that, the advice you usually hear is to take a walk or try a gentle class. Hardly anyone tells you to go pick up a dumbbell. A meta-analysis published in November 2026 suggests maybe someone should.

Women's Health, the US edition, has run about a dozen pieces on mental health since mid-August 2026. One of them covered a University of Limerick trial in which young women with anxiety lifted weights. Here we'll look at two big meta-analyses on weights and depressive symptoms, what they found, and what they can't tell you.

The new study pooled 80 trials

O'Sullivan, Herring and colleagues at the University of Limerick in Ireland worked with researchers from the University of Wisconsin-Madison and published the paper in JAMA Network Open. They pulled together 80 randomized trials with 6,123 people in all. The average participant was 57, and 67.1% were women.

Every trial measured depressive symptoms with a validated rating scale, once at the start and again at least 3 weeks later. Some compared weights with doing nothing, usual care or a waiting list. Others set weights against things people also try for their mood: aerobic exercise, relaxation, stretching, mind-body exercise, nutrition programs, or education and advice sessions. That second group is what makes this paper worth reading.

Against doing nothing, lifting cut symptoms by a moderate amount

Start with the easy comparison. Against people in an inactive group, those who lifted saw their symptoms drop by a moderate amount, with an effect size of 0.54. That lines up with the same group's earlier work. In 2018, Gordon and colleagues pooled 33 trials and 1,877 people in JAMA Psychiatry and found an effect of 0.66, with a number needed to treat of 4. For every four people who trained, one more improved than would have without it.

Next to other activities, the edge gets smaller

The 2018 study left a question hanging. Do weights help more than other things you could do, or only more than nothing at all? The new paper goes right at it. Against active comparisons, weights still came out ahead, but only by a little, with an effect of 0.21. Across all comparisons the figure was 0.32, which the authors themselves call small.

The split that matters most is who was doing the lifting. Against active comparisons, the effect was 0.40 in people with a mental illness and 0.11 in people without one. So if you've been diagnosed with a mental health condition, that's where weights seem to bring something of their own. If you don't have a diagnosed disorder, they still help. The gap between them and those other activities is just small.

Don't read too much into that 0.21, though. The comparison group mixed aerobic exercise and stretching with education sessions and nutrition advice, so it doesn't show that weights beat cardio. In another meta-analysis we've covered on the blog, walking or running came out slightly ahead of strength training in people with major depression.

You don't need long sessions

Some groups saw bigger effects against inactive comparisons. In trials that enrolled only women, the effect was 0.87. Sessions of 30 minutes or less reached 1.75, but the margin of error around that number was so wide that it tells you little on its own. The safe way to read it: short sessions didn't come out worse. Short on time during the week? Then that's good news.

The 2018 paper adds a useful detail. The relief wasn't significantly linked to how much training people were prescribed, or to whether they got measurably stronger. How often they trained did matter in the new study, though: against doing nothing, trials with 4 or more days a week showed bigger effects.

The fine print on both studies

Both papers pool trials that were very different from one another, and results varied a lot in each. The better trials, the ones that concealed which group people would land in, found smaller effects. In the new study, that figure was 0.32 against inactive comparisons. The 2018 paper saw the same pattern in trials that blinded allocation or assessment.

Then there's who took part. The average age was 57, and 57 of the 80 trials enrolled people who had an illness. If you're 40 and healthy, the data can guide you, but most of it came from people who were older or living with an illness. These studies also tracked symptoms on rating scales, and lifting isn't a substitute for treatment. If you've gone weeks without wanting to do anything, talk to your doctor or a psychologist first.

What to change on Monday

Keep your walk or your gentle class. It helps too, and nothing here says you should drop it. These trials compared weights with other activities and didn't test the two together, so adding weights to what you already do is a reasonable choice, not a proven one.

Sessions of half an hour or less fall within what was tested. To start, big movements like squats, rows and presses are enough, with a weight that makes the last few reps hard. If you're a woman going through menopause, we've covered why strength training helps in that stage.

We've also covered how exercise eases low mood, and a bit more in a group. At Gym Triple X you get both in the same room: the weights and the people. Picking exercises and knowing when to add weight is easier with someone next to you, especially during a stretch when just getting started feels hard. A personal trainer on the Costa del Sol can put together short sessions that fit the week you actually have.

Sources

  1. JAMA Network Open (2026). Resistance Exercise Training for Depressive Symptoms.
  2. JAMA Psychiatry (2018). Association of Efficacy of Resistance Exercise Training With Depressive Symptoms.